Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Value Line again

As noted here I recently sold a long term poorly performing investment in the Value Line Fund mutual fund. I was unaware at the time of the information in this story about the end of the less than successful reign of the daughter of Value Line's founder. It appears I would have been wise to get out long ago since among other things it appears the mutual fund was paying inflated commissions:

Value Line found another way to profit from its mutual funds, according to the SEC—by overcharging customers. Starting in 1986, when Mrs. Buttner was president but not yet CEO, the company began what the SEC calls a “fraudulent practice” of sending mutual fund trades to brokers who charged inflated commissions and then kicked back a portion of the commissions to Value Line.

This is an example of the perils of nepotism. It appears making your daughter your successor because you can't find anyone else is not the best plan:

Mrs. Buttner was appointed president of Value Line in 1984 by her father, who had looked in vain both inside and outside the family for a successor; she became CEO upon his death three years later. ...

And a reason past performance does not guarantee future results as the disclaimers say. I guess paying a bit more attention to my investments is indicated.

1 comment:

  1. Mrs. Buttner should go to jail, and the investors should get some of their money back due to the illegal nature of the kickbacks. Perhaps no one can be trusted to make money for the investors, family member or not. Perhaps nepotism is not the issue, but rather dishonesty.

    December 9, 2009 8:04 AM
    Add profile picture
    Change image Select image to upload

    From the web
    This image will be added to your Blogger profile and will appear next to new comments.


    Mrs. Buttner should go to jail, and the investors should get some of their money back due to the illegal nature of the kickbacks. Perhaps no one can be trusted to make money for the investors, family member or not. Perhaps nepotism is not the issue, but rather dishonesty.

    Comment as: Select profile... James B. Shearer (Google) LiveJournalWordPressTypePadAIMOpenID Name/URLAnonymous Edit Settings – Sign out
    Subscribe by email

    ReplyDelete