Sunday, December 1, 2013

Blog Roll

I have removed Nate Silver's 538 blog from my blog roll until such time as it restarts following Silver's move from the NYT to ESPN.  I have added educationrealist a blog by a high school math teacher which seems mostly consistent with my views on education.  Namely that the public schools are doing about as well as can be expected and that the main reason some kids do better academically than other kids is that some kids are smarter than other kids.

I have also added the Mr. Money Mustache blog by a man who retired (sort of) at age 30 by saving a ridiculous fraction of his income.  I find his point of view interesting although I often disagree with it.  And there would be problems if everyone tried to adopt his ideas.

I would like to add Kevin Drum's blog at Mother Jones to my blog roll but I have never been able to get the link to work properly in the Blog List widget.  For some reason it sends you someplace else in the Mother Jones website although the link works fine in the body of a post as above.  If anyone knows how to fix this let me know.

Saturday, November 30, 2013

James Welles Shearer

My father, James Welles Shearer, received a physics PhD from MIT around 1950.  Around 1958 he started working at what is now the Lawrence Livermore National Lab (LLNL).  He continued to work there until his death in 1984.  While there he wrote a number of scientific papers and technical reports. These were mostly about high magnetic fields and various aspects of proposals for controlled nuclear fusion.  He seems to have generally published as "JW Shearer".     

I have set up an author page for him on Google Scholar which lists his papers with citation counts. I relied on Google's clustering algorithm to generate the list of papers.  I didn't see any that obviously aren't his but there could be omissions.

Thursday, November 28, 2013

End this Depression Now

I recently read "End this Depression Now" a 2012 book by Paul Krugman about our current economic problems and what to do about them.  I thought it was fairly good although I do not share Krugman's liberal politics.  Krugman's books are more balanced and less polemical than his NYT newspaper columns making them more palatable to me.  Despite the title most of the book is devoted to discussing our current problems and how we got into them.  Less space is devoted to Krugman's ideas for fixing things.  Perhaps because, despite Krugman's protestations to the contrary, he realizes they are nonstarters politically.

Krugman's diagnosis is that our current sluggish economy reflects an overall lack of demand.  There are idle resources but businesses are unwilling to hire people and increase production because they fear (with good reason) that they will be unable to sell the resulting goods and services.  I find this plausible.  A competing explanation cites structural problems, that the economy is set up to produce the wrong things and that time is needed retrain workers and refit factories.  I don't  find this convincing.  If overall demand was adequate but not matched to supply you would expect to see shortages developing and prices rising for those goods and services in strong demand as well as idle capacity in areas of weak demand.  But for the most part this isn't happening.  Now structural problems could become a problem as the economy improves.  I am not convinced that estimates of current capacity generated by naive extrapolation of pre-crisis GNP trends are realistic.  But I don't think structural problems are currently a binding constraint.

I find Krugman's explanations for the origin of the lack of demand and ideas for fixing things less convincing.  He appears to believe that the economy has multiple equilibrium conditions and that although the economy is currently in a unfavorable equilibrium condition (into which it was pushed by the financial crisis) there is also present a preferable full capacity equilibrium.  So all that is needed is temporary government actions to push the economy into the more favorable equilibrium where it will remain by itself without needing continuing support.  For my part I doubt this more favorable equilibrium actually exists (under current conditions) making policy attempts to push the economy into it futile and potentially dangerous. 

One point of disagreement is whether the lack of demand is a chronic condition.  Certainly there was a temporary aspect, the financial crisis panicked people into trying to increase savings (or reduce debt) and due to the well known "paradox of thrift" this leads to a drop in demand.  But the acute phase of the financial crisis is long past, people are no longer panicked but demand remains depressed.  I think this reflects an underlying structural problem which needs to be addressed.  Krugman dismisses my favored explanation briefly in a paragraph on p. 83.

For example, one popular story about inequality and crisis--that the rising share of income going to the rich has undermined overall demand, because of the shrinking purchasing power of the middle class--just doesn't work when you look at the data.  "Underconsumption" stories depend on the notion that as income becomes concentrated in the hands of a few, consumer spending lags, and savings rise faster than investment opportunities.  In reality, however, consumer spending in the United States remained strong despite growing inequality, and far from rising, personal saving was on a long downward trend during the era of financial deregulation and rising inequality. 

I find this unconvincing.  Personal saving is measured on a net basis which can hide a growing imbalance as part of the population saves more and more while another part spends more than their income and goes deeper and deeper into debt.  This can maintain demand for a while but isn't sustainable indefinitely.  Eventually the indebted portion of the population reaches their borrowing limits and is forced to cutback on consumption while the savers continue to try to save leading to a drop in demand.  This looks to me a lot like conditions before and after the crisis point. 

Krugman has two main ideas for improving the economy, pushing up the inflation rate and a temporary deficit financed surge in government spending.  Both seem politically difficult at present which in my view is just as well as I find them uncongenial.

The rationale for increasing inflation is that this would allow additional cuts in the real interest rate (which is currently constrained by the inability to reduce nominal interest rates below zero, "the zero bound").  But I am unconvinced that any benefits would exceed the costs.  Krugman suggests a relatively benign sounding increase from 2% to 4% but it is unclear why this would be enough to have a significant effect.  Perhaps an increase to say 12% would be needed which sounds a lot less benign.  In any case, as Krugman acknowledges, an increase in the inflation rate also has large distributional consequences favoring debtors at the expense of  savers.  So having a lot of savings myself I am not inclined to support increased inflation.

The rational for increasing government spending is to increase overall demand encouraging businesses to expand.  I don't doubt it would have some such effects in the short run but am less convinced they would be sustainable.  As noted above while Krugman believes temporary deficits would be sufficient to push the economy into a more favorable equilibrium I am not convinced.   A political issue is what to spend the money on, there aren't that many uncontroversial and clearly temporary projects for the government to fund.  Krugman points out that crisis imposed budget problems led state and local governments to lay off many workers (deepening the crisis) and argues that this could have been prevented by increased federal aid to local governments.  But while this might have been a good idea several years ago it is entirely unclear that federal aid to hire all those workers back is a good idea now. There are other problems, some of the increased demand will be reflected in increased imports.  This could significantly reduced any benefits to the US economy.  US policy cannot really be evaluated in terms of purely domestic effects. 

Krugman also discusses Europe's troubles.  He attributes many of them to the formation of Euro zone with which I agree, the Euro was clearly a mistake.  But it is unclear how to fix things, as Krugman states unraveling the Euro would be very costly but there are also serious problems with keeping it as it forces an inappropriate uniformity of policy throughout the Euro zone.

In summary this book is a reasonable explication of conventional liberal thought about the economy.  However it is not all that original, I didn't find it to offer a lot of fresh ideas which I hadn't encountered before.  Another issue is the political discussion (which speculates about the outcome of the 2012 elections) is a bit dated.  Nevertheless it is reasonable introduction to the issues from a liberal point of view.

Monday, November 11, 2013

Obama's Lie

Over the years President Obama has made many statements to the effect that if you liked your current health insurance plan you would be allowed to keep it under his plan.  It is now obvious that these statements were incorrect.  Moreover I think it is fair to characterize them as lies.  First the blanket nature of the statements was unrealistic, even with the best intentions it is hard to make major changes in the health care system while preserving for everyone an option to continue with their existing plans.  Second and more importantly it was always a fundamental part of Obama's program that healthy and unhealthy people would pay the same rate for health insurance even if their expected claims costs were vastly different.   This meant forcing everyone into the same new risk pools where they would pay a blended rate.  Allowing healthy people to keep cheap existing plans catering to healthy people was at odds with this objective.  As a result the Obama administration didn't make a sincere good faith effort to allow as many of these people as possible to keep their existing plans (and thus stay out of the new risk pools).  Instead they wrote regulations that intentionally made it difficult for existing plans to qualify for exemptions from the law's new requirements.  As a result millions of people in the individual health insurance market are now being forced to find new plans regardless of their wishes contrary to Obama's repeated assurances that they would have the option of keeping their existing health insurance.  This was planned and not some unanticipated accident.  So it is hard for me to see why Obama's false statements shouldn't be called lies.

Of course politicians in general lie a lot so this is not some unique sin of Obama's.  He was not the first American President to lie to the American people and he won't be the last.  One of the (many) things that irritated me about President Carter was his claim that he would never lie.  In my view a more honest man would have pledged to try to minimize his lies which Carter was failing to do every time he pledged never to lie.  In any case just because many politicians have lied in the past and will lie in the future doesn't mean they shouldn't pay a political price when caught.  It appears Obama is paying such a price and he deserves to.  If he and his administration had devoted less effort to selling their plan politically and more to developing a sound and workable (which probably implies less ambitious) plan they and the nation would be better off today.

Wednesday, October 9, 2013

Local Supermarkets

Early this year one of the supermarkets near my townhouse, the Super Fresh in Plainsboro, closed.  This didn't bother me much as I think I had only shopped there once.  However this week I learned the Stop&Shop a few miles up Route 1 is also going to close.  This is more bothersome as I had shopped there fairly often and will miss it.  According to the article at the Stop&Shop link there are plans to build a Shop-Rite supermarket a bit south on Route 1 (which would be closer to me) so maybe things will eventually work out for the better.

Apparently the Stop&Shop is the third supermarket to fail at that spot in a 20 year period.  This is a bit surprising as it seems like a good location with easy access to Route 1.   But perhaps the population density in the immediate vicinity is not as high as it could be.  I hadn't seen any indications of distress at the store, although in hindsight perhaps the fact that (at least at the times I was there) most of the checkout stations did not need to be staffed was a bad sign.    

Monday, October 7, 2013

The Signal and the Noise

I recently read "The Signal and the Noise" by Nate Silver.  Nate Silver became well known because of the political analysis and generally accurate election predictions in his blog 538.  Earlier he had developed a successful system, PECOTA, for predicting the development of minor league baseball players.  In this book he attempts a general survey of forecasting.  I found the book a bit disappointing (perhaps in part because I had excessively high expectations).

One problem with the book is that when Silver moves away from his specific areas of expertise he makes mistakes showing he has failed to completely grasp the material.  On page 110 Silver writes:

... They are hot: the 77 trillion calculations that the IBM Bluefire supercomputer makes every second generate a substantial amount of radiant energy.  They are windy: all that heat must be cooled, lest the nation's ability to forecast its weather be placed in jeopardy, and so a series of high-pressure fans blast oxygen on the computers at all times.  ...

Here "radiant energy" is at best a confusing way of saying heat.  And I had never heard of oxygen (as opposed to simple air) cooling.  In any case according to NCAR:

Bluefire relies on a unique, water-based cooling system that is 33 percent more energy efficient than traditional air-cooled systems. Heat is removed from the electronics by water-chilled copper plates mounted in direct contact with each POWER6 microprocessor chip. ...

The chess diagram on page 271 is obviously wrong (the pawn on g2 should be on g3) and the related statement on page 270:

These databases relied on the assumption, however, that Kasparov would respond as almost all other players had when faced with the position, by moving his knight back out of the way. ...

is simply false, the usual move is bg2, retreating the knight would be very weak.

On page 374 Silver writes:

The greenhouse effect is the process by which certain atmospheric gases - principally water vapor, carbon dioxide (CO2), methane and ozone - absorb solar energy that has been reflected from the earth's surface.  ...

Here "reflected" should be "absorbed by and re-radiated".  The key point is because the sun is hotter than the earth solar radiation has shorter wavelengths than the earth's heat radiation.  Greenhouse gases absorb more strongly at longer wavelengths hence block more of the outgoing radiation as compared to the incoming solar radiation.  The effect is to warm the earth's surface.  On the other hand sunshine reflected from the earth's surface remains shortwave and leaves as easily as it arrived.

These (and other similar) errors aren't critical to Silver's arguments and could be fixed without too much trouble but they diminish the reader's general confidence in the author's reliability.  Silver would have done better to have had subject matter experts check for this sort of thing. 

The book has other problems.  At 454 pages it is quite long and there are things like the chapter on the Kasparov - Deep Blue match which could have been cut without too much loss. 

I didn't care for the analysis of the failure of the rating agencies prior to the recent financial crisis.  Silver discusses technical issues but the real problem is the agencies are paid by the people selling the securities they are rating.  This gives them an obvious incentive to fudge their ratings.  Silver understands this when it comes to political polling, polls paid for by a candidate will generally report more favorable results for the candidate than neutral polls.  In the case of political polls the amount of fudging is limited by the existence of neutral and opposition polls.  There were few such countervailing forces when it came to rating complex mortgage backed securities and the rating agency fudging got totally out of hand.  At the end nearly worthless securities were being given AAA ratings.  Silver largely ignores the bad rating agency incentives which remain in place and seem likely to cause similar problems in the future.

I don't want to be too negative, the book contains some interesting material and I agree with a lot of Silver's conclusions.  But I can't really call it a must read.      

Tuesday, October 1, 2013

Yarnell Hill Fire

On June 30, 2013 a crew of 19 firefighters was killed by the Yarnell Hill Fire near Yarnell Arizona.  Recently a report was released on an investigation of this event.  In my view the report is seriously flawed, showing an undue reluctance to criticize the decisions that led to 19 deaths.  The report claims it is trying to avoid hindsight bias, the tendency to label decisions as wrong when they work out badly even if they were actually reasonable under the circumstances.  This is a commendable goal but it has to be balanced against the need to identify avoidable mistakes.  Simply refusing to judge decisions is not the proper balance.

The report refers to decisions made by the crew and speculates about the thinking behind them.  But I expect the crew as a whole was not making decisions, instead the decisions were made by the crew's leaders (who appear to have been two men which the report does not name).  If 19 people are killed in plane crash the investigation will naturally focus on the pilots.  What was their training, experience, reputation?  Similarly one would expect this report to discuss the background of the fire crew leadership but in fact it provides no information at all.  Also in recent years there has been much attention paid to cockpit dynamics.  For example if the pilot makes a mistake does the co-pilot feel free to object.  Again this report does not discuss the analogous fire crew dynamics at all.      

The fire crew was killed while apparently attempting to move from one safe area to another (perhaps as the report speculates because they felt the second area would leave them better positioned for further firefighting efforts, although it should be noted the overall leadership did not expect or particularly want them to do this).  In doing so they chose a route that placed them in mortal danger.  Initially they moved on a two track road along a ridge.  This seems to have been reasonably safe at least at first as they had a view of the fire and various retreat options if it moved towards them.  However they then left the road (which would have eventually taken them to their apparent goal) to descend off the ridge through a box canyon directly towards their destination (a ranch with a cleared area).  Although this was a shorter route than continuing along the road it probably wasn't quicker as it was much heavier going.  The report speculates that the ranch appeared closer than it was and that they didn't realize how slow the going would be.  The real problem however was once they left the ridge they lost sight of the fire and (according to the report) the ability to perceive the wind shift that drove the fire towards them.  By the time they realized they were in danger it appears it was too late to do anything.  The report lists some of their options at the point they left the ridge but does not discuss one possibility.  Why didn't they leave a scout on the ridge to keep watch on the fire and warn them if it started to move towards them?  They had utilized a scout earlier in the day in what seems like a less dangerous situation so why not here?  The report doesn't discuss this.

The report doesn't want to admit that any mistakes were made.  This makes it hard to identify problems and make improvements going forward.  The report's view is that firefighting is inherently dangerous and that these 19 deaths were just one of those things.  I am not convinced.

Added 12/25/2013:  I fixed the link to the report.  Some other material including a video was also released.